Worst PR examples

by: Rebecca

May 20th, 2010

There’s no such thing as negative press; what a load of rubbish! I accept that notoriety amongst certain celebrities has earned them significant revenues but that’s just personality prostitution.

The rest of us see loss of reputation and negative press as disastrous to our businesses. We all make mistakes but unfortunately the attention we receive for our failures, in our society, is magnified.  The dilemma is, that we need to learn from our mistakes to make progress.

When I’m dishing out yet another personal critical review I like to remind myself that companies with lots of money and expertise often get it badly wrong. Here are some classic PR mistakes and well publicised examples: 

Product issues

Toyota recoils over recalls

The brand has been badly damaged and reputation of Japanese car makes ruined by the recall of over 8m cars.

Persil’s rotten lot

Persil Power was meant to clean clothes at lower temperatures but it soon emerged that its new catalyst attacked certain dyes in clothes beyond repair. Pictures soon circulated of rotting clothes.

Bernard’s birds get flu

Sales plummeted and several countries banned UK poultry imports following an outbreak of bird flu at the Bernard Matthews farm. The brand struggled to recover. 

Poor planning 

Extra time at Wembley stadium

The new building was a year late and 400m over budget.

Opening of Terminal 5 at Heathrow

BAA hoped to put an end to “Heathrow hassle” but upon opening made it a great deal worse with one in five flights cancelled.

Ikea Stampede in Edmonton

20 people needed hospital treatment following the midnight opening of the new store. The 6000 shoppers, entertained by fire eaters and stilt walkers, were turned away after just 40 minutes when security fled and ambulances arrived to treat customers with heat exhaustion and crush injuries.

 

No understanding of target audience

Ratner’s owner jokes his product is rubbish

500m was wiped off the value of the high street jewellery chain after its owner claimed its goods were substandard. During his infamous speech he stated a sherry decanter was cheap because it was “total crap” and that his earrings were cheaper than a prawn sandwich but wouldn’t last as long.

Topman at Topman insults customers

Topman’s chief was quoted branding its customers as “hooligans” and claimed that its clients only wore suits for court cases.

Barclaycard chief loses his credit

Barclaycards top exec was quoted saying that smart customers should steer away from credit cards.

(examples above taken from various telegraph.co.uk articles)

Can anyone else think of any big PR disasters that I can console myself with when I am confronted with another learning experience!

VN:F [1.8.4_1055]
Rate This Post!
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

Best and worst companies during the travel chaos

by: Rebecca

May 13th, 2010

As discussed in my last entry I was astounded at the short sightedness by the majority of companies seeking to limit their costs and even capitalise on the recent travel chaos rather than creating invaluable great PR.

My husband and I were congratulating ourselves on how lucky we had been to fly out of Heathrow an hour before all the airports were closed. Increasing concern replaced our smugness , with every passing day, as we heard more shocking and appalling tales of the treatment of stranded travellers. We began to appreciate the potential gravity of the situation we were now in. This transcended to panic by the end of the week when our fears were confirmed, that we too had been stranded in Dubai with our one year old son.

I feel unable to name and shame, on our website, the well known companies that we discovered had dumped their customers with no help or empathy, or even worse the ones that sought to capitalise from them.  I will name the companies I had a direct experience with.

My PR shame list

As we were independent travellers our insurance did not cover us. Imagine how much extra business an insurance company would gain from advertising that they were the only company that did pay out!

Travel companies hid behind the “act of God” clause in their terms and conditions. I was appalled to hear how passengers travelling, with well known operators, had been dumped and told to sort the problem out themselves.

Hotels and car hire companies increased their rates by as much as three times to capitalise on distressed and stranded passengers. I also understand that many refused to refund customers or allow them to alter their dates.  A bit of empathy with their customers would have gained more credibility then could ever be achieve by expensive advertising campaigns. So many businesses promote themselves on their customer service and this was the opportune time to prove it.

I appreciate that this is a pretty unique situation but there was simply no excuse for the poor information and lack of sympathy from these businesses to their most valuable assets, their customers. Even though the airspace had been reopened I could not get through to any representative at Royal Brunei. The website claimed that all confirmed flights were leaving as scheduled.

Our airline, being international, had no legal obligation to get us back home for “acts of God”. Our flight was confirmed but Royal Brunei still left us waiting at an empty check in desk before sending out a terrified, lone representative, an hour late to advise us all that they had given our seats away.

The only word to describe the airports was chaos. I simply couldn’t believe how rude and aggressive some customer service staff I encountered were. At the airport, in Paris, staff had misplaced our pushchair. This was particularly distressing for me as, by this point, my son had not slept for a day and I faced a 15 hour wait for my next flight with a writhing, exhausted one year old. A mother in tears did not evoke any kind of sympathy so my husband was forced to create such a fuss security had to be called. Only then did we get any help!

How much great PR would have been gained by companies going to the airports offering free services, care and assistance for stranded passengers? What an easily missed opportunity 

Some companies, however, behaved superbly and proved to be real champions of customer service.

My PR fame list

Our knight in shining armour came in the form of Air France. Whilst the poor Royal Brunei representative was fighting off customers like a swarm of angry wasps, we jumped at the opportunity when Air France offered to get us to Paris on a flight leaving in 30 mins. They did not charge us, they processed our tickets quickly and efficiently, their customer service at check in and on the flight was outstanding, and they upgraded us to business class and gave my son his own seat. Not only this but they sorted a flight to Heathrow and arranged for our luggage to be waiting for us. Other passengers told us how they had also been rescued by Air France from all over the world. They are my customer service hero’s!!!  I will from now on always try to use them and endorse them at any opportunity. 

I was also pleased to discover that the company I used for airport parking “Heathrow Drive Fly” were offering customers full refunds, or changing dates and not profiting from extended stays.

Good PR does not come from announcing a new product or service and pestering journalists with dull press releases. It comes from going beyond what a customer expects, standing out from the competition and smart, creative thinking. Excellent customer service at Duport is our priority and my faith has been restored that we are not alone in our genuine care for our customers.

Can anyone else shame or fame a company?

VN:F [1.8.4_1055]
Rate This Post!
Rating: 4.5/5 (2 votes cast)

What is PR?

by: Rebecca

May 10th, 2010

Simply defined PR is your reputation. It is how others perceive and talk about what you do and what you say. Your reputation is not only how the public perceives you but also how your staff views you.  Having a well known, good, reputation will not only ensure you continue to attract lots of business, you will also attract and retain the best employees who then create and strengthen your reputation and the cycle continues….

A great reputation is not gained through expensive sales and marketing strategies. True, these will bring customers to your door but if you do not meet their expectations you will quickly loose their business as well as that powerful, word of mouth recommendation we all strive for. 

As society we tend to focus on the negative and your mistakes are disproportionally more costly. Harsh but true, your reputation will be discussed more frequently if it is negative rather than positive.

PR is not advertising, you do not pay the media to talk about your company. Getting the media to talk about your company in a positive way is far more difficult (and the real art of good PR) than a juicy piece of negative press the journalists know we all love.  

Having first hand experience of the recent travel chaos I was astounded at the wasted PR opportunities by the majority of companies directly involved. Astonishingly this is at a time when certain businesses desperately need to increase their creditability amongst their customers and staff.

I know the problems have cost billions but did anyone account for the cost of the terrible PR.  How can these companies be so short sighted especially when they spend millions on sales and marketing? 

How do you ensure that you create a positive reputation?

VN:F [1.8.4_1055]
Rate This Post!
Rating: 4.0/5 (2 votes cast)